diff --git a/freerelay/control_plane/experiments/replay.py b/freerelay/control_plane/experiments/replay.py
index d09908f..ea9326e 100644
--- a/freerelay/control_plane/experiments/replay.py
+++ b/freerelay/control_plane/experiments/replay.py
@@ -148,7 +148,7 @@ async def load_outcomes(
 
             logger.info("replay_loaded_outcomes count=%d", len(records))
 
-        except Exception:
+        except (aioredis.RedisError, ValueError, TypeError):
             logger.exception("load_outcomes_error")
 
         return records