[TRENDS] Aggregate analysis at 475 issues — 2026-05-21

[akaszubski]

Summary

475 auto-improvement issues filed to date (42 open, 433 closed — 91% resolution rate). Last trends report at 420 issues (2026-05-02, 19 days ago).

Recurring Pattern Frequency (All Time)

Pattern	Count	Status
[ORDERING]	49	Active — 3 open
[BYPASS]	41	Active — 3 open
[HOOK-REGRESSION]	27	Active — 2 open
[DOC-VERDICT-MISSING]	26	Active — 1 open
[INCOMPLETE]	22	Stable — 0 open
[DENY-WORKAROUND]	12	Active — 1 open
[GHOST]	11	Stable — 0 open
[CIRCUMVENTION]	7	Stable — 0 open
[TIMING]	5	Active — 1 open
[GAMING]	3	Stable — 0 open

Enforcement Promotions Since Last Trends

• [CI] Agent completeness gate deny message leads with broken env-var bypass — apply 89393fb pattern #1086: Agent-completeness deny message leads with file-based bypass — message clarity hardened
• [CI] Pipeline has no runtime-behavior test axis — subprocess/CWD bugs pass static+mock gates and ship #1067: 6th plan-critic axis "Operational Integration Test" added — plan review more thorough
• [#1075 sub-issue] /triage --auto-improvement periodic pass — root-cause grouping of CIA queue #1099: /triage --auto-improvement periodic-aggregation pass — CIA queue now has root-cause clustering

New Patterns This Period

Four new issue classes from batch 20260521-214143:

1. Reviewer pytest-artifact friction ([CI] Reviewer requests pytest artifact but cannot call pytest — recurring REQUEST_CHANGES on missing process artifact #1108) — Reviewer cannot call pytest; requests artifact it cannot obtain. Recurs for issues with no pre-run test output. Affects ~10% of batch issues.

2. Mode auto-detector over-defaulting to full ([CI] Mode auto-detector errs toward 'full' when no signals match — 5 coordinator overrides in one batch #1109) — 5/21 issues (24%) had coordinator override auto-detected mode from full to fix. Heuristics under-detect small bug fixes.

3. Already-done batch waste ([CI] Already-done issues in batch waste pipeline cycles — batch triage should detect prior-commit implementations #1110) — 2/21 issues (9%) were already implemented but still OPEN. No pre-flight already-done check exists.

4. Settings guard blocks template work ([CI] Issue #557 settings guard fires when settings TEMPLATE is the work product — self-maintenance mode gap #1111) — Harden agent identity: CLAUDE_AGENT_NAME is trivially spoofable #557 guard fired on legitimate template edits; required universal bypass instead of targeted relaxation. Self-maintenance mode should cover this case.

Root-Cause Clusters

Cluster A: Coordinator Context Management (highest frequency)

ORDERING (49) + BYPASS (41) + DENY-WORKAROUND (12) all share the root: coordinator makes decisions without sufficient context about pipeline state, prior bypass history, and gate order. Recommended: coordinator context injection at STEP 3 — inject current pipeline_completion_state before each agent dispatch.

Cluster B: Doc-Master Completeness (26 issues)

DOC-VERDICT-MISSING recurring despite fix attempts at #906. The background-launch pattern is inherently fragile. Consider switching doc-master to inline (synchronous) execution.

Cluster C: Pipeline Mode Detection (new pattern emerging)

Mode auto-detector false-full classification + already-done detection gap + reviewer artifact friction are all variants of: coordinator makes expensive decisions with incomplete issue signals. A single "issue pre-flight" step (mode detection + already-done check + pytest pre-run) could address all three.

Resolution Rate Trend

Snapshot	Total	Open	Closed	Resolution %
180 issues (2026-03-29)	180	~40	~140	78%
370 issues (2026-04-17)	370	~43	~327	88%
420 issues (2026-05-02)	420	~42	~378	90%
475 issues (2026-05-21)	475	42	433	91%

Resolution rate trending up. Open backlog stable at ~42 issues — healthy.

Recommended Next Actions

1. File and implement "issue pre-flight" step in batch coordinator (addresses [CI] Reviewer requests pytest artifact but cannot call pytest — recurring REQUEST_CHANGES on missing process artifact #1108, [CI] Mode auto-detector errs toward 'full' when no signals match — 5 coordinator overrides in one batch #1109, [CI] Already-done issues in batch waste pipeline cycles — batch triage should detect prior-commit implementations #1110)
2. Extend self-maintenance mode to relax settings guard for template paths ([CI] Issue #557 settings guard fires when settings TEMPLATE is the work product — self-maintenance mode gap #1111)
3. Investigate doc-master background-launch reliability — 26 issues suggest systemic gap ([CI] [DOC-VERDICT-MISSING] doc-master completion events absent — 4 missing in run 20260508-212809 (#852 regression) #1061)
4. ORDERING pattern (49 issues, 3 still open) — worth a dedicated enforcement pass

Plugin Version: 3.50.0 (f6f264c)

---

Filed automatically by continuous-improvement-analyst

[akaszubski]

Deferred from batch /implement run 2026-05-24 — TRENDS aggregate analysis at 475 issues is a human-review artifact (read + decide), not an implementable change. Recommend reviewing the trends report manually and filing concrete action issues, then implementing those.

[akaszubski]

Reviewed in batch batch-20260524-214009 — this is an aggregate trends report (auto-filed by continuous-improvement-analyst), not implementable code. The 'Recommended Next Actions' propose filing other issues, which is downstream triage work. Leaving open for human review; closing once recommendations are absorbed into separate work items.

[akaszubski]

Preflight skip (batch 20260524-230923): [TRENDS] aggregate analysis issue is a meta-report (475 issues, 91% resolution rate), not implementable code. Consistent with prior batch determination (merge 3cd6c5c).