Skip to content

work-closeout should always include the Love Gate #386

Description

@cellmechanic

Problem

The work-closeout skill appears to be invoked for closeout requests without reliably including the required Love Gate section in the final closeout response.

The skill contract currently says:

## The Love Gate

Before finalizing the closeout, perform a "Love Gate" check.
...
- **Report findings**: Include a brief "Love Gate" section in your closeout summary.

The output format also lists:

- Love Gate: what you love about the results, and anything you do not love.

Recent transcript evidence

Local session history shows a user correction after an attempted closeout flow:

2026-06-10 15:01:28Z user: use the closeout skill
2026-06-10 15:10:37Z user: what about the love gate and the rest of the skill

There are also nearby direct closeout requests in recent local history, e.g.:

2026-06-10 14:35:40Z user: ok great, use the closeout skill
2026-06-10 15:50:31Z user: can you use the work closeout skill
2026-06-16 17:20:44Z user: ok use the work closeout skill

Those suggest this is not just a one-off prompt phrasing issue; closeout requests are common and the required Love Gate is easy for the agent to skip unless the user explicitly asks for it.

Expected behavior

When work-closeout is used and the response is a closeout/safe-to-exit summary, the final response should include a visible Love Gate item/section, even if it is brief.

Examples:

Love Gate: I like that the docs and PR state are clean. I do not love that the validation was docs-only, but that is appropriate for this change.

or, in a compact final:

Love Gate: Clean and complete; no lingering smells beyond the intentionally deferred follow-up.

Suggested fix

  • Add behavior validation that fails if a closeout/safe-to-exit response omits Love Gate when work-closeout is triggered.
  • Consider moving the Love Gate requirement closer to the top of the skill or into a non-optional closeout checklist, since the current section exists but is still being skipped in practice.
  • If the final response is very short, still require a one-line Love Gate entry rather than dropping it.

Acceptance criteria

  • A closeout prompt such as use the work closeout skill produces a final answer with a Love Gate section/item.
  • A safe-to-exit prompt that routes through work-closeout also includes Love Gate before the Safe to exit answer or near it.
  • Behavior tests or harness fixtures cover this so regressions are caught.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

No labels
No labels

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions