Skip to content

Commit a52ec21

Browse files
committed
more
Signed-off-by: Yosh <github@yosh.is>
1 parent a647369 commit a52ec21

1 file changed

Lines changed: 19 additions & 7 deletions

File tree

‎proposals/0005-structured-labels/README.md‎

Lines changed: 19 additions & 7 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -99,10 +99,10 @@ been filed specifically for the agenda, and whether any items need attention.
9999
| `lifecycle/blocked-on-author` | `S-waiting-on-author` |
100100
| `lifecycle/confirmed` | `S-confirmed` |
101101
| `lifecycle/duplicate` | (1) |
102-
| `lifecycle/fixed` | `S-fixed` |
102+
| `lifecycle/fixed` | (2) |
103103
| `lifecycle/needs-review` | `S-needs-triage` |
104-
| `lifecycle/not-a-bug` | (2) |
105-
| `lifecycle/wont-fix` | (3) |
104+
| `lifecycle/not-a-bug` | (3) |
105+
| `lifecycle/wont-fix` | (1) |
106106
| `question` | `C-question` |
107107
| `ready-for-review` | `S-waiting-on-review` |
108108
| `regen-goldens` | `S-needs-golden-regen` |
@@ -113,9 +113,9 @@ been filed specifically for the agenda, and whether any items need attention.
113113
| `size/xl` | `E-hard` |
114114
| `size/xs` | `E-easy` |
115115

116-
- 1: Link issue and close as not planned
117-
- 2: Explain the finding and close as not planned
118-
- 3: Close as not planned
116+
1. Link issue and close as "not planned"
117+
2. Close the issue as "completed"
118+
3. Explain the finding and close as "not planned"
119119

120120
### New labels
121121

@@ -180,4 +180,16 @@ up for agendas to discuss as part of triage.
180180
### Why is “participation” labeled with “E-”
181181

182182
“Priority” is labeled “P-”, meaning participation needs a different prefix. Rust
183-
uses “E-” which seems as good as any other.
183+
uses “E-” for this, which seems as good as any other choice.
184+
185+
### Why rename "lifecycle" to "status"
186+
187+
The term "lifecycle" implies that it can only represent one state at any given
188+
time, e.g. *"Which state in the lifecycle are we on?"*. The term "status" does
189+
not imply that same restriction, and any item can have one or more status
190+
modifiers at any given time.
191+
192+
This is nice, because it allows us to tag an item as `S-waiting-on-review`,
193+
while also being `S-nominated` for the next community meeting. In comparison:
194+
"nominated for the next meeting" does not feel like it would naturally be part
195+
of any "lifecycle".

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)