Building on Humble with Colcon

[beshankulapala]

Is there a port or guide to build this package on humble ? On humble catkin is having all sorts of issues, and lots of forums point to Colcon as the tool to build. Appreciate your help. Newbie here, sorry if this is not the right place to ask this question. Thanks !

[Timple]

This package is not yet ROS2 compatible. Some effort has been made on the galactic branch.

Can you try that branch to see if it works?

[joeldushouyu]

It did compile with Galactic !

[joeldushouyu]

I am wondering if this has a ros2 version documentation.

I am willing to help testing this package in the ros2 environment if needed.

[Timple]

We have discussed this internally and we'll make an effort to support ros2 humble as well. I'll keep you posted!

[mikolodz]

Hi @Timple ! What's the current status of the ROS2 branch? Should I consider using it in my simulation or is it highly unlikely that it's going to be usable in the nearest future? Thank you a lot!

[Timple]

It should be operational for Humble. Please go ahead and try it out!

edit: documentation etc are not up to date yet.

[mikolodz]

It should be operational for Humble. Please go ahead and try it out!

edit: documentation etc are not up to date yet.

Hi Timple!

I've successfully build the project with your full_coverage_path_planner package and all the dependencies (at least the ones I'm aware of). But I'm not sure how to run the test examples.

I have copied the launch files into the ./install/full_coverage_path_planner/share/full_coverage_path_planner/ folder.

When I try to run the launch file example I'm getting the error:

$ ros2 launch full_coverage_path_planner test_full_coverage_path_planner.launch 
[INFO] [launch]: All log files can be found below /home/administrator/.ros/log/2023-06-16-15-08-37-447741-administrator-VirtualBox-118378
[INFO] [launch]: Default logging verbosity is set to INFO
[ERROR] [launch]: Caught exception in launch (see debug for traceback): Caught exception when trying to load file of format [launch]: Error trying to process rule "substitution":

Unknown substitution: find

Maybe you could give me some hints how to launch the examples? I've read your documentation in this repo, but it seems not to apply to the ros2 branch.
Thank you!

edit:
I replaced the substitutions "find" with "find-pkg-share" within the launch file and the error changed to:

ros2 launch full_coverage_path_planner test_full_coverage_path_planner.launch
[INFO] [launch]: All log files can be found below /home/administrator/.ros/log/2023-06-16-16-18-30-170012-administrator-VirtualBox-119430
[INFO] [launch]: Default logging verbosity is set to INFO
[ERROR] [launch]: Caught exception in launch (see debug for traceback): Caught exception when trying to load file of format [launch]: Attribute exec of type <class 'str'> not found in Entity node

It's the first time I'm trying to fix a launch file, so I'm not sure what I'm doing.. rotfl

edit 2:
Migration process for launch files is described here:
Migrating launch files from ROS 1 to ROS 2

I tried to apply most of the changes, but the error message is still the same which doesn't help with debugging. Also, when using --debug param in the launch command is not helping, because I'm getting no trace about which particular line in the xml launch file causes the error.

ros2 launch full_coverage_path_planner test_full_coverage_path_planner.launch --debug

I assume that you must have some testing script that you've beed using during the migration process to Ros2. Could you consider sharing it here or in the repo? Even if it's just a simple dirty snippet, it would help a lot! I would really appreciate that!

[mikolodz]

Hi @Timple,
By any chance could you give me some hints on how should I proceed?
It's been two weeks since I'm stuck and I'd really love to take a chance and test your module.

Thank you so much!

[rikhsitlladeveloper]

Hi @Timple, By any chance could you give me some hints on how should I proceed? It's been two weeks since I'm stuck and I'd really love to take a chance and test your module.

Thank you so much!

Hello @mikolodz.

Did you get any update?

I am also starting to use this package for ROS2 Humble. Getting error for launching.
If you have any update pls share.
Thanks

[mikolodz]

Hi @Timple, By any chance could you give me some hints on how should I proceed? It's been two weeks since I'm stuck and I'd really love to take a chance and test your module.
Thank you so much!

Hello @mikolodz.

Did you get any update?

I am also starting to use this package for ROS2 Humble. Getting error for launching. If you have any update pls share. Thanks

Hello, no, I didn’t succeed.

Maybe you could take a look into the fields2cover lib (2.0)? In the opennav_coverage ROS2 project, there is a pull request regarding the official support of the F2C. Unfortunately, It’s frozen from a while now, because it failed the tests.

You can refer to this issue (with the F2C 2.0 feature list):
Fields2Cover/Fields2Cover#73 (comment)

And this PR (integration with ROS2):
open-navigation/opennav_coverage#53 (comment)

If you find a way to make it running (F2C or FCPP), please let me know! :)

Regards!

[jkoubs]

Hi @Timple @mikolodz and @rikhsitlladeveloper @beshankulapala ,

I’m also interested in integrating this package into ROS 2 Humble. Just checking in, has there been any update or progress on getting it to work?
If anyone has managed to get it running or has tips for the integration with ROS 2 I’d really appreciate your insights!

Thanks!

[newkillerwhale]

嗨，您能给我一些提示吗？我已经两周没有遇到困难了，我真的很想抓住机会测试一下你的模块。 非常感谢！

您好。
您收到任何更新吗？
我也开始将这个软件包用于 ROS2 Humble。启动时出错。如果您有任何更新，请分享。谢谢

你好，不，我没有成功。

也许你可以看看 fields2cover lib （2.0）？在 opennav_coverage ROS2 项目中，有一个关于 F2C 官方支持的 pull request。不幸的是，它现在已经冻结了一段时间，因为它没有通过测试。

您可以参考此问题（使用 F2C 2.0 功能列表）：Fields2Cover/Fields2Cover#73（注释）

还有这个 PR（与 ROS2 集成）：open-navigation/opennav_coverage#53（评论）

如果您找到运行它的方法（F2C 或 FCPP），请告诉我！:)

问候！

哦，又有一个ros2的nav2全覆盖需求者出现了，请问您现在对于将full_coverage_path_planner整合到nav2中有什么头绪吗