-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 8
Description
In line 366, the values of e_weight are set to (1/w if w>0 else 1) for w in authorwt. Why?
Assuming that the w values in authorwt correspond to edge degrees, it seems to lead to an incorrect computation of v_reg_sum.
Using this hypergraph as an example:

(Changing the indices from 1-based to 0-based)
authorwt = [ 2 , 4 , 1 ]
paper_author[0] = [ 0 , 0 ]
paper_author[1] = [ 1 , 0 ]
paper_author[2] = [ 1 , 1 ]
paper_author[3] = [ 2 , 1 ]
paper_author[4] = [ 3 , 1 ]
paper_author[5] = [ 3 , 2 ]
paper_author[6] = [ 4 , 1 ]
Following line 366
e_weight[0] = 0.5
e_weight[1] = 0.25
e_weight[2] = 1
Assuming alpha_v = 1, the results of line 382 should be:
e_reg_weight[0] = 0.5
e_reg_weight[1] = 0.5
e_reg_weight[2] = 0.25
e_reg_weight[3] = 0.25
e_reg_weight[4] = 0.25
e_reg_weight[5] = 1
e_reg_weight[6] = 0.25
And paper2sum in line 383 should be:
paper2sum[0] = [0.5]
paper2sum[1] = [0.5, 0.25]
paper2sum[2] = [0.25]
paper2sum[3] = [0.25, 1]
paper2sum[4] = [0.25]
Then in line 393, v_reg_sum should be:
v_reg_sum[0] = 0.5
v_reg_sum[1] = 0.75
v_reg_sum[2] = 0.25
v_reg_sum[3] = 1.25
v_reg_sum[4] = 0.25
But according to the definition of the normalisation denominator in the the paper:

the denominator matrix should be:
[0] [1] [2] [3] [4]
[0] 2 0 0 0 0
[1] 0 2+4 0 0 0
[2] 0 0 4 0 0
[3] 0 0 0 4+1 0
[4] 0 0 0 0 4
By setting the values of e_weight in line 366 to w instead, we get:
e_weight[0] = 2
e_weight[1] = 4
e_weight[2] = 1
Then the results of line 382 should become:
e_reg_weight[0] = 2
e_reg_weight[1] = 2
e_reg_weight[2] = 4
e_reg_weight[3] = 4
e_reg_weight[4] = 4
e_reg_weight[5] = 1
e_reg_weight[6] = 4
And paper2sum in line 383 should become:
paper2sum[0] = [2]
paper2sum[1] = [2, 4]
paper2sum[2] = [4]
paper2sum[3] = [4, 1]
paper2sum[4] = [4]
Then in line 393, v_reg_sum should be:
v_reg_sum[0] = 2
v_reg_sum[1] = 6
v_reg_sum[2] = 4
v_reg_sum[3] = 5
v_reg_sum[4] = 4
which corresponds to the definition given in the paper. Ditto for v_weight and e_reg_sum.