Skip to content

:root selector for scoped CSS #1601

New issue
New issue
Open
Open
:root selector for scoped CSS#1601
Labels
discussionfeature requestscoped css
@davidhewitt

Description

@davidhewitt
davidhewitt
opened on Oct 22, 2019

What problem does this feature solve?

Often when I'm writing scoped CSS for my components I need to put a class on the root element so that I can style it. For example:

<template>
    <div class="foo-root">Hello World</div>
</template>

<style scoped>
    .foo-root {
        color: red
    }
</style>

What does the proposed API look like?

CSS already supports a :root selector which means the "root HTML element of the document" (i.e. usually the <html> element).

As far as I know it's never possible for a component to be the root <html> element of the document. So this :root selector effectively does nothing inside scoped CSS.

Therefore, why not repurpose it to mean the component's root element? We could then re-write the example above without needing to add a specific class:

<template>
    <div>Hello, World</div>
<template>

<style scoped>
    :root {
        color: red;
    }
</style>

Admittedly a small idea, but one that I think would save a fair bit of typing (and inventing class names)!

Activity

bpolaszek

bpolaszek commented on Dec 19, 2019

@bpolaszek
bpolaszek
on Dec 19, 2019

+1024 for this one!

haoqunjiang
added
discussion
feature request
scoped css
on Dec 27, 2019
adi518

adi518 commented on Mar 15, 2020

@adi518
adi518
on Mar 15, 2020

I had this in mind as well, good idea.

jfbrennan

jfbrennan commented on Apr 13, 2020

@jfbrennan
jfbrennan
on Apr 13, 2020 · edited by jfbrennan

Guys :root really means <html> and that meaning is very much cemented. Vue shouldn't mess around with that.

:host is closer to what you're looking for and it's what Riot.js uses for this same use case, so support for that in Vue would be much appreciated!

jfbrennan

jfbrennan commented on Apr 13, 2020

@jfbrennan
jfbrennan
on Apr 13, 2020

...come to think of it, the solution can be as simple as:

<template>
  <div>
    // other markup
  </div>
</template>

<style scoped>
  div:first-child { ... }
</div>

Maybe this is what a lot of people already do?

davidhewitt

davidhewitt commented on Apr 13, 2020

@davidhewitt
davidhewitt
on Apr 13, 2020 · edited by davidhewitt
Author

:host seems like a better alternative to the :root I originally proposed!

davidhewitt

davidhewitt commented on Apr 13, 2020

@davidhewitt
davidhewitt
on Apr 13, 2020
Author

Or to think of it... how about $el?

If that's valid CSS syntax - would be really natural to use given $el is already how we access the component's element inside <script>...

bpolaszek

bpolaszek commented on Apr 19, 2020

@bpolaszek
bpolaszek
on Apr 19, 2020

...come to think of it, the solution can be as simple as:

<template>
  <div>
    // other markup
  </div>
</template>

<style scoped>
  div:first-child { ... }
</div>

Maybe this is what a lot of people already do?

I just tried it, and it doesn't work.
Besides, this assumes you have a knowledge of the first element being a div, meaning this could not applied to this:

<template>
    <a v-if="isLink" href="...">{{ text }}</a>
    <span v-else>{{ text }}</span>
</template>

:host or :root appear like more generic solutions.

bpolaszek

bpolaszek commented on Apr 20, 2020

@bpolaszek
bpolaszek
on Apr 20, 2020

@davidhewitt In my opinion:

:host looks semantically like a new concept, it sounds like "we couldn't use :root so we had to find another term".

$el doesn't look CSS at all.

As you pointed out, :root means "root HTML element of the document" (i.e. usually the element) - so it totally makes sense in a scoped context.

@jfbrennan :root doesn't necessarily mean <html>, according to MDN:

The :root CSS pseudo-class matches the root element of a tree representing the document.
In HTML, :root represents the element and is identical to the selector html, except that its specificity is higher.

Perfectly fine in our case IMHO.

jonaskuske

jonaskuske commented on Apr 22, 2020

@jonaskuske
jonaskuske
on Apr 22, 2020

it sounds like "we couldn't use :root so we had to find another term".

:host is a normal CSS pseudo-class though, and it is absolutely appropriate here since Vue’s component syntax is loosely modeled after the [Web Component] spec.

$el doesn't look CSS at all.

True.

@jfbrennan :root doesn't necessarily mean <html>, according to MDN:

The :root CSS pseudo-class matches the root element of a tree representing the document.
In HTML, :root represents the element and is identical to the selector html, except that its specificity is higher.

Perfectly fine in our case IMHO.

What about this sounds "Perfectly fine"? 😅 The definition you yourself have quoted states:
"In HTML, :root represents the element and is identical to the selector html"

Yes, :root doesn't necessarily mean html because it can be used in SVG documents, too – but this is quite clear-cut, usage in HTML → html selector → impractical for the proposed usage as Vue component root.

davidhewitt

davidhewitt commented on Apr 22, 2020

@davidhewitt
davidhewitt
on Apr 22, 2020
Author

FWIW, if anyone's feeling passionate about pushing this forward and has a spare evening, it would probably be a great time to write a Vue 3 RFC on this feature. Especially inspiration could be drawn from vuejs/rfcs#119

(I'm too busy on other projects at the moment or I might have considered writing the RFC myself)

bpolaszek

bpolaszek commented on Apr 22, 2020

@bpolaszek
bpolaszek
on Apr 22, 2020

:host is a normal CSS pseudo-class though, and it is absolutely appropriate here since Vue’s component syntax is loosely modeled after the [Web Component] spec.

My bad, I should have googled more 😅I definitely thought it was an invention of some framework to do the trick we wanted to copy/paste. I go back on my word then, :host sounds better indeed 🙂

giftkugel

giftkugel commented on Jun 24, 2020

@giftkugel
giftkugel
on Jun 24, 2020 · edited by giftkugel

Is this issue stalled?

I would like to upvote the:host suggestion. Why? because it is necessary to select the root element of a component without using an id or class attribute. I think it is important for re-useable components.

Example structure

<template>
    <div>
        <div>Hello World</div>
    </div>
</template>

Setting a style for the outer div cannot be accomplished with div:frist-child (as suggested in this thread) because it would also match the inner div.

Using a CSS class with scoped context leads to a HTML document which is not nice when the component is used

<template>
    <div class="foo">
        <div>Hello World</div>
    </div>
</template>
<style scoped>
.foo {
    color: red
}
</style>

When someone now uses my component

<Foo></Foo>

and adds a CSS class called "foo"

<Foo class="foo"></Foo>

the generated HTML looks like

<div class="foo foo" data-v-654321 data-v-123456>
    <div>Hello World</div>
</div>

I just want to use styles inside my component for my root element without weird CSS usage.

So I would love to use

<template>
    <div>
        <div>Hello World</div>
    </div>
</template>
<style scoped>
:host {
    color: red
}
</style>

Which then should lead to

<div class="foo" data-v-654321 data-v-123456>
    <div>Hello World</div>
</div>

when used as described above.

10 remaining items

Loading
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    discussionfeature requestscoped css

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

        Participants

        @ByScripts@vzakharov@jfbrennan@davidhewitt@haoqunjiang

        Issue actions
          :root selector for scoped CSS · Issue #1601 · vuejs/vue-loader