Add orogenic setup cookbook with documentation#923
Conversation
d14a164 to
03c2d82
Compare
Pull Request Test Coverage Report for Build 23756492231Details
💛 - Coveralls |
|
@Kaili270 : Thank you for contributing this, is this ready for review? |
87d7211 to
ceaaeb8
Compare
ceaaeb8 to
5d7aeb7
Compare
Kaili270
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This is ready for review. Thank you so much.
Hi Alarshi, Cheers, |
|
alarshi
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@Kaili270 : Thank you for adding this cookbook, this is cool! I just one comment and a few minor comments after which I can take another look.
Could you explain to me why you wanted to separate the compositional fields of the upper crust, lower crust, lithosphere, and asthenosphere between domain 1 and 2 for the stable continental region? Are you planning to use different properties? Since, world builder automatically replaces the previously computed values for a given region, you could also simply your input files by first specifying the horizontally uniform layers and then adding the orogen? Here is the file for reference (github does not allow .wb attachment). This approach would reduce the number of your compositional fields from 12 to 7, and even more if you decide to use the same compositional value for the layers within the orogens. Feel free to structure your .wb file different, I am just interested in your reasoning.
| :::{literalinclude} ../3d_cartesian_orogenic_setup.wb | ||
| :language: json | ||
| :lineno-start: 1 | ||
| ::: |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This includes the complete .wb file. Is there a specific section you want to add? Maybe you can just add one of the layers and describe in the text as "The relevant part of the World Builder file describing the upper crust is shown below:" and then you would add the specific lines as:
| :::{literalinclude} ../3d_cartesian_orogenic_setup.wb | |
| :language: json | |
| :lineno-start: 1 | |
| ::: | |
| :::{literalinclude} ../3d_cartesian_orogenic_setup.wb | |
| :language: json | |
| :lineno-start: 1 | |
| :lines: 10-32 | |
| ::: |
You could also make the file compact by including the coordinates in a single line.
| ----------- | ||
|
|
||
| In this setup, we define a three-dimensional model domain with dimensions of 500 km in the x-direction, 2000 km in the y-direction, and 200 km in the vertical (z) direction. | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Could you add the model figure here. i.e., Figure_1_setup.png? I have some recommendation for modifying your figure as well. Could you rotate the view so that it looks similarly to the temperature figure? Please remove the axes grid labels as well as it is a bit hard to read, but you can annotate the axes separately using an external software (e.g., paint, photoshop etc. ). It would also be nice to see the different layers if you annotate the layers, i.e., upper crust, lower, crust, mantle lithosphere, asthenosphere, instead of reading it in the figure label.
| 3D Cartesian Orogenic Setup | ||
| ====================== | ||
|
|
||
| A three-dimensional Cartesian model representing an idealized orogenic system with laterally variable lithospheric structure. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Could you add some motivation here? Something like "Earth’s lithospheric thickness varies spatially depending on the tectonic setting. In this cookbook, we describe the implementation of a thickened lithospheric root beneath an orogen due to isostasy."
This PR adds a new cookbook demonstrating an orogenic setup using WorldBuilder.
The example includes:
This setup can serve as a starting point for studies on lithospheric inheritance.
I would appreciate any feedback or suggestions.
Kai