Skip to content

Two-GPU tensor parallelism for 16 GB boards — would you consider it, or parts of it? #313

Description

@ValerioDolci

Hi, thanks for NInfer. I know the README keeps multi-GPU out of the product boundary, so I'm asking before sending anything.

Qwen3.8-27B NVFP4 doesn't fit one 16 GB board, so I built an experimental --tp 2 --devices A,B mode on top of current master (bace20dc), building on the earlier TP2 forks (wamansou, ivanov84, parallelno). It lives in a fork: https://github.com/ValerioDolci/ninfer-tp2 (Known limitations in its README).

What it covers: ordinary decoding, --spec mtp, --spec dflash2 --lm-head-draft, prefix reuse, concurrent requests, CUDA Graph decode and --vision, with bf16/int8 KV. On two RTX 5070 Ti without P2P: decode 58 t/s plain, 110 MTP3, 118 DFlash2 at short context; GSM8K 0.975-0.98 (vLLM same weights 0.98); ctest 144/150 (the 6 failures are the tp 1 real-model tests, which do not fit 16 GB).

Design points relevant to upstream:

  • --tp 1 is meant to stay identical: the two-device paths are separate, and the few shared changes are listed per commit.
  • Weights are sliced at load time from the existing artifacts (no new artifact format).
  • 92 linear commits, grouped so they can be reviewed in pieces: independent fixes → multi-GPU primitives → split ops and shard shapes → sharded loading → two-device forward/Program/Engine → MTP → DFlash2 → tuning → Vision.

Some commits fix things that also matter on one GPU and could come first regardless of the rest:

  • the KV execution row republished on every prefill step (a stale row after a forced token);
  • kernel function attributes set per device instead of once per process;
  • rejecting nvfp4 TMA linear_add geometries without a route, and unsupported head counts in the causal-cache dispatch.

Would you be interested in (a) those standalone fixes, (b) the two-GPU mode as an opt-in, or neither? Happy to split, rebase or rework to your conventions.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions