Skip to content

Conversation

@heyitsnoah
Copy link
Owner

Summary

This PR adds comprehensive PDF processing capabilities to claudesidian, enabling users to split PDFs into individual page images and analyze them with Gemini Vision AI.

What's New

πŸ–ΌοΈ PDF Splitting

  • pdf-split.sh: Convert PDFs into individual page images
  • pdf-to-images.mjs: Node.js script for high-quality PDF-to-PNG conversion
  • Creates organized folders with indexed markdown files for each PDF

πŸš€ Batch Processing

  • pdf-parallel-processor.sh: Process multiple PDFs concurrently
  • Optimized for performance with configurable parallel workers
  • Automatic progress tracking and statistics

πŸ€– AI Analysis

  • pdf-gemini-analyze command: Process PDF images with Gemini Vision
  • Three modes: extract (text only), analyze (full analysis), summarize (condensed)
  • Intelligent batching for optimal API usage
  • Parallel processing for multiple PDFs

Technical Details

  • Added pdf-to-img dependency for PDF processing
  • Scripts use bash and Node.js for cross-platform compatibility
  • All scripts follow existing code style and linting rules
  • Integrates seamlessly with Obsidian's attachment structure

Use Cases

  1. Academic Research: Split research papers and textbooks for detailed analysis
  2. Document Archival: Convert PDFs to images for better Obsidian integration
  3. AI-Powered Analysis: Extract insights from visual documents
  4. Batch Processing: Handle large document libraries efficiently

Testing

  • βœ… Scripts copied from production vault where they're actively used
  • βœ… Linting and formatting applied
  • βœ… Dependency added to package.json

Example Usage

# Split a single PDF
.scripts/pdf-split.sh "05_Attachments/document.pdf"

# Process all PDFs in attachments folder
.scripts/pdf-parallel-processor.sh

# Analyze PDFs with Gemini Vision
/pdf-gemini-analyze all analyze

Files Changed

  • Added 3 new shell/Node.js scripts in .scripts/
  • Added 1 new command in .claude/commands/
  • Updated package.json with pdf-to-img dependency

πŸ€– Generated with Claude Code

- Add pdf-split.sh script to convert PDFs to individual page images
- Add pdf-to-images.mjs Node.js script for PDF conversion
- Add pdf-parallel-processor.sh for batch processing multiple PDFs
- Add pdf-gemini-analyze command for AI-powered PDF analysis
- Add pdf-to-img dependency for PDF processing
- Enables splitting PDFs into images for better Obsidian integration
@heyitsnoah
Copy link
Owner Author

@claude please review

@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Sep 18, 2025

Claude finished @heyitsnoah's task β€”β€” View job


βœ… Code Review Complete

Todo List

  • Check for CLAUDE.md files for repo guidelines
  • Review new command files (.claude/commands/)
  • Review shell scripts (.scripts/)
  • Review Node.js script (pdf-to-images.mjs)
  • Check package.json changes
  • Review CHANGELOG.md updates
  • Provide comprehensive review feedback

Overall Assessment

This is a well-crafted PR that adds valuable PDF processing capabilities to claudesidian. The implementation is solid with good code quality, proper error handling, and excellent documentation. The CI checks are passing, and the code follows the repository's linting standards.

✨ Strengths

  1. Excellent Documentation: Both command files are thoroughly documented with clear examples, use cases, and expected outputs
  2. Performance Optimization: Parallel processing implementation with configurable workers shows attention to performance
  3. User Experience: Clear progress indicators, error messages, and success summaries throughout
  4. Integration: Seamless integration with Obsidian's markdown format and attachment structure
  5. Code Quality: Clean, well-commented code that passes all linting checks

πŸ” Code Quality Review

Shell Scripts (.scripts/)

pdf-split.sh βœ…

  • Good error handling with set -e
  • Clear usage instructions and colored output for better UX
  • Proper path handling with quotes for spaces
  • Creates useful index markdown file for Obsidian integration

pdf-parallel-processor.sh βœ…

  • Excellent parallel processing implementation using background jobs
  • Configurable worker count (defaults to 8)
  • Progress tracking and statistics
  • Handles large batches efficiently

Node.js Script

pdf-to-images.mjs βœ…

  • Clean async/await implementation
  • Proper error handling with try/catch
  • Good CLI argument parsing
  • Configurable scale factor for quality control

Command Files (.claude/commands/)

Both command files are exceptionally well-documented with:

  • Clear processing phases
  • Intelligent batching strategies for API optimization
  • Progress tracking with TodoWrite
  • Error resilience
  • Structured output formats

⚠️ Potential Issues & Suggestions

  1. Cross-Platform Compatibility

    • Line 87 in pdf-split.sh: realpath --relative-to may not work on macOS without GNU coreutils
    • Consider adding a fallback or checking for command availability
    # Suggestion: Add compatibility check
    if command -v grealpath &> /dev/null; then
        REALPATH_CMD="grealpath"
    elif command -v realpath &> /dev/null; then
        REALPATH_CMD="realpath"
    else
        # Fallback to relative path handling
    fi
  2. Resource Management

    • The parallel processor defaults to 8 workers which might be aggressive for some systems
    • Consider detecting CPU cores: MAX_PARALLEL=${1:-$(nproc 2>/dev/null || sysctl -n hw.ncpu 2>/dev/null || echo 4)}
  3. Error Recovery

    • In pdf-parallel-processor.sh, failed jobs aren't tracked properly (FAILED variable is never incremented)
    • The process_pdf function returns 1 on failure but this isn't captured in the background job
  4. Security Consideration

    • File paths are properly quoted which is good
    • Consider adding validation for PDF file format before processing
  5. Memory Usage

    • Large PDFs converted at scale 2.0 might consume significant memory
    • Consider adding a warning or memory check for files over a certain size

πŸ“ Minor Observations

  1. CHANGELOG.md: The changes aren't documented in the unreleased section yet
  2. Dependencies: pdf-to-img is a good choice - lightweight with minimal dependencies
  3. Index Generation: Smart to generate markdown indexes for Obsidian navigation

🎯 Recommendations

  1. Add the cross-platform compatibility check for realpath
  2. Fix the FAILED counter in the parallel processor
  3. Consider adding these features to CHANGELOG.md under [Unreleased]
  4. Optional: Add file size warnings for large PDFs

βœ… Verdict

This PR is ready to merge with the minor caveat about cross-platform compatibility. The code is well-written, properly documented, and adds valuable functionality to the project. The parallel processing implementation is particularly impressive.

Great work on this feature! The attention to detail in both implementation and documentation is excellent. πŸš€

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants