Skip to content

Conversation

avishwak
Copy link

No description provided.

@super30admin
Copy link
Owner

  1. Correctness:
  • Problem 1 (Search a 2D Matrix): The solution correctly implements binary search on a flattened 2D matrix. It handles edge cases well (empty matrix or matrix with empty rows).
  • Problem 2 (Search in Rotated Sorted Array): The logic is mostly correct but has a bug. Using nums.index(target) defeats the purpose of binary search and makes it O(n) in worst case. The second if should be an elif to avoid unnecessary checks.
  • Problem 3 (Search in Infinite Sorted Array): The solution correctly implements the two-phase approach (finding bounds then binary search) and handles the ArrayReader interface properly.
  1. Time Complexity:
  • Problem 1: Correctly identified as O(log(m*n))
  • Problem 2: Claimed O(log n) but due to the index() call, it's actually O(n)
  • Problem 3: Correctly identified as O(log n)
  1. Space Complexity:
  • All problems correctly identified as O(1) space complexity.
  1. Code Quality:
  • Generally good with clear comments and structure.
  • Variable names are appropriate.
  • The bug in Problem 2 and the redundant condition check are the main quality issues.
  • Could benefit from more consistent docstring formatting across files.
  1. Efficiency:
  • Problem 1 is optimal.
  • Problem 2 could be made more efficient by removing the index() call and using the binary search properly.
  • Problem 3 is optimal.

Areas for Improvement:

  • Remove the index() call in Problem 2 and properly implement binary search.
  • Change the second if to elif in Problem 2 to avoid redundant checks.
  • Consider adding more edge case tests (e.g., single element arrays, target not present, etc.).
  • Make docstrings more consistent across files.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants