Skip to content

Topic names conflict with their descriptions and linked standards #11

Description

@ShiroKSH

Summary

Fourteen topic records have names that describe a different skill from the rest of the record. I limited this list to cases where the description, evidence, assessment prompt, linked standards, and dependency reasons consistently point to the same replacement.

Topic ID Current name Content-supported name
mt_7IFpDVNsmt Classifying living things Gathering, Recording, Classifying and Presenting Data
mt_rDjtmDogJr Classifying living things (age 9+) Recording Data and Results
mt_bfhng6mOuy Angles in triangles (age 6+) Defining Attributes of Shapes
mt_zuOGOGFAKb Angles in triangles (age 7+) Recognising and Drawing Shapes by Attributes
mt_Xt1cRqaBOW Understanding angles (age 8+) Classifying Quadrilaterals
mt_GzcJEVkNRn Understanding angles (age 8+) Area of Rectangles by Multiplication
mt_tAJH5BrpOx Angles in triangles (age 11+) Perimeter, Area and Volume Formulae
mt_1VmTUxBrNd Types of angles (age 13+) Applying Pythagoras' Theorem
mt_y-BuQAfw4B Coordinates (age 12+) Similarity and Enlargement
mt_vmW2cb5c7A Ratio (age 10+) Mental Calculation Strategies
mt_X5cypSGoGU Ratio (age 11+) Priority of Operations
mt_MCu_SNg_OW Arrays for multiplication (age 9+) Short Division with Remainders
mt_r8XnXwRA6g Representing numbers with objects (age 8+) Scaled Picture and Bar Graphs
mt_3tz3Otap5j Halves and quarters (age 7+) Money Word Problems

Examples of the mismatch

  • mt_X5cypSGoGU is named “Ratio (age 11+)”, but its description and evidence are exclusively about BIDMAS, powers, roots, and operation priority; its linked UK standard is titled “Priority of Operations”.
  • mt_GzcJEVkNRn is named “Understanding angles (age 8+)”, but every content and dependency field concerns calculating rectangle area by multiplying side lengths.
  • mt_7IFpDVNsmt is named “Classifying living things”, while both linked UK standards and all content concern recording and presenting experimental data in tables, diagrams, and graphs.

The strongest pattern is an age-progression label apparently carrying onto a neighbouring curriculum skill: both Ratio records and both Classifying living things records are affected, as are several records in the angle-name families.

Suggested fix

Please update the source-of-truth/export step and regenerate the published data rather than hand-editing only this JSON snapshot. The stable IDs, descriptions, evidence, prompts, standards, and graph relationships can remain unchanged; only the corrupted names and resulting manifest checksum/byte count should need updating.

I can prepare the data PR once the intended source-of-truth workflow and names are confirmed.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions