You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
[Task] Import Elsa 3 Templates source and history without publishing #8748
Delivery program: #8740. Native parent Feature: #8744; Epic #8197. This task starts only after Apps #8746 is accepted. Operations owner: #8741.
Objective
Import the Elsa 3 .NET project Templates repository into templates/, retaining original source/history/attribution and the Elsa.Templates package plus elsa-server, elsa-studio and elsa-combined commands. Deliver source acceptance with real isolated pack/install/generate/build proof; publishing remains separate.
Current evidence and adoption
Readiness discovery pinned main 8917597: 65 tracked files; package 3.9.0; 20 existing option-matrix smoke cases; source release tags 3.8.0/3.9.0 retained. Refresh all branches/tags/open PRs/issues before import and again at closeout. No matching import PR was found at discovery.
Source PR #9 (5dc2c5c) adds the combined-server custom-element registration missing on current main. The API is confirmed in Studio release 3.9.0. Retain its original commit/author and carry the reviewed applicable change after the immutable original-main import. Do not silently copy a stale source branch over newer main and do not automatically close the donor PR. Preserve issue #3 as an attributed report; do not claim AmbiguousMatchException fixed without reproduction evidence.
Scope
Immutable original import with all tracked paths/modes/blobs mapped to templates/; retain all reachable source commits/tips including open contribution heads, original IDs and authors. Follow with a separate minimal integration delta.
Inspect original instructions, product solution, independent packaging and embedded starter projects. Preserve all tracked sample/standalone assets with explicit dispositions; embedded template .csproj files are data, not root build projects.
Isolate inherited Core MSBuild/CPM/source-proof/NuGet restore behavior locally. Preserve package and target/dependency identities. Do not add source project references or join a lockstep release stream.
Correct package source-repository metadata for Core commit provenance and corresponding assertions; retain original donor metadata in the original import/history.
Move smoke temporary workspaces outside the consolidated checkout so generated projects cannot inherit Core policy, preserve isolated dotnet template hives and deterministic cleanup.
Add correct root/product solution/filter, navigation, AGENTS/developer commands and narrowly triggered nonpublishing CI. Retain nested source publishing metadata inert; do not activate upload/trust/updater/retirement jobs.
Use current source acceptance matrix (20 smoke cases plus meaningful applicable-fix regression), real local pack, isolated installation, generation and generated-output builds. Supported default is released Elsa 3.9.0; history coverage of 3.8.x is separate and does not invent runtime support. Record any actual unsupported option/provider failure.
Acceptance
Exact original tree/mapped assets and source history/refs verified; current arrivals and contributor work explicitly reconciled.
Elsa.Templates identity, three commands, supported options and product release independence preserved; all tracked inputs retained or explicitly dispositioned.
Root/product build/solution/filter/docs and nonpublishing CI integrate correctly without compiling embedded starter data or activating publishers.
Real local pack/install/generate/build lifecycle and existing supported smoke matrix pass with exact-head hosted evidence; failures and skips remain explicit.
Fresh author-independent Elsa3CodeReview APPROVE/HIGH, required current-head Greptile 5/5, advisory disposition and applicable CI pass before normal shared/main integration. Lead independently reads back source tree/parents/mapping and final freshness.
One active delivery task across board #52. Use /implement, isolated worktree and per-slice branch from latest origin/codex/elsa-integration-program; adopt matching PRs. Sol 6.1 High implementation, Luna 6 Extra High bounded independent review; lead integration/QA and public writes. Initial checkpoint: refreshed source/history topology, exact mapping, concrete integration plan and cost-ordered validation commands before editing. Preserve canonical dirty checkouts. No source repository writes, push/publication/merge from worker. Avoid repeating expensive gates for verifier/docs-only fixes; native CI supplies coherent exact-head evidence. Apps source-restore and selector lessons must be verified for Templates too.
Accepted source slice
PR #8750 merged into shared at 5403eda00557c20e39306863d53213afb7308e55. Actual-main integration and final cutoff remain #8749/#8740; operational delivery remains #8741.
Templates #8748 is the sole active delivery Task after Apps source acceptance. Board: In Progress / Assigned / Pending. Sol6.1High worker owns the first bounded mapping checkpoint; lead retains integration, public writes, review and QA.
Isolated branch codex/elsa-templates-source-8748 starts from accepted shared merge 1d5bc1e1deaba8f2d90920109061a3504a945106, in /Users/sipke/.codex/worktrees/elsa-templates-8748-delivery/elsa-core-main. Clean HEAD/status verified. The actual Git worktree is valid; app registration and one retry hit the existing100attachment limit, which does not change isolation or require touching user checkouts.
Fresh donor main is unchanged at 891759727db053a37911b616ace4a5599e1005d0; advertised release refs and sole open sourcePR9 5dc2c5cf4eb6ed17b2228912f712993e48adb56b are recorded. No matching Core Templates import PR exists. First checkpoint precedes edits and covers complete original-tree/history mapping, retained contribution attribution and applicable PR9 registration fix, local MSBuild/CPM/NuGet inheritance, independent template-pack/solution boundaries, isolated generated workspaces/hives and concrete20case pack/install/generate/build validation.
No publisher activation, package upload, donor PR closure, retirement, archive, full release certification or Elsa4 work is assigned. Future candidate/archive compatibility remains with #8741/#8220. Final source audit and actual-main integration follow Templates; the program remains open.
Templates implementation checkpoint: the immutable import f1aaec368a9ad317093c71c993fb51eca2544e9e preserves the exact original tree 0de85b0ca906f6be6559998768378f5c9fb03bb6, all 65 path/mode/blob mappings and all 41 original commits. The lead independently verified the eight ancestry parents and all retained ref commits. Applicable donor PR #9 is a separate attributed application commit 79469e023b7a26b0ff6ca3a5a64104f654466ea2; its original commit and author timestamp remain retained.
The separate Templates product solution/filter, scoped build/restore policy, outside-checkout test workspaces, root navigation and nonpublishing CI are implemented locally and undergoing review. Initial cheap checks passed: solution/filter generation, source-impact boundaries, retained publisher guards, Ruby dependency census and actionlint. Provenance/corruption tests and review fixes are still being completed. No native .NET or Docker proof has run locally on the overloaded shared host; exact-head hosted restore/build and all 20 real pack/install/generate/build cases remain required before acceptance.
Fresh donor main/release refs and outstanding source contributions are unchanged. The 35 accepted Core/Studio/Extensions release refs still match #8624 with no new unregistered 3.8.x/3.9.0 refs; Templates retains its 3.8.0 and 3.9.0 history. #8748 remains the only active delivery Task. #8749 stays queued for final source cutoff, actual-main integration and complete source closeout; operational work stays with #8741.
Templates PR #8750 is open at 4752f5e7d4159fe7fb2aeb4a07e2c971ff62fc19. Independent source reviews approve that commit, but hosted lifecycle verification found a real build failure: 20 starter cases executed, 13 passed and 7 combined-host cases failed with CS1061 at the adopted custom-element registration. No merge or acceptance is claimed. The correction is in progress in the isolated Templates worktree; exactly one delivery task remains active. Owned expensive superseded CI runs were cancelled to avoid duplicate proof work.
Current Templates source checkpoint: PR #8750 is at 02ee01951e44ba8ce83a10750a25c11bcee25947, with fresh independent Spec and Standards APPROVE/HIGH. The missing released namespace is corrected, with focused source regression and real20-case CI in progress. Greptile completed its predecessor4752 review at3/5 and identified additional missing custom-element registration in standaloneStudio and combinedWASM entrypoints. This is a genuine source-acceptance blocker covering the same starter setup as adopted donorPR9; the minimal correction and generated-output coverage are in progress. Owned expensive supersededCI was cancelled. No merge or acceptance is claimed.
The inherited Monaco and production signing-key observations have byte-identical donor provenance, documented limitations and explicit operational handoff to #8741: #8741 (comment) . These are distinct from the bounded registration acceptance fix. #8748 remains the sole active Task; #8749 stays queued.
Current complete-registration head c8d670e1681661f9c8a8873b1c2e8819e4ec1edb passed the real20-case Templates lifecycle; the lead independently verified TRX, scoped restore graph and artifact digest. Evidence: #8750 (comment) . Fresh exact-head independent reviews approve. Broader CI/package proof and Greptile remain in progress; #8748 stays the sole active Task, In Progress / In Review / Running. Final #8749 source cutoff/main integration remains queued.
Exact-head checkpoint for PR #8750 at c8d670e1681661f9c8a8873b1c2e8819e4ec1edb:
Templates native run38187935974: 20 total/executed/passed, zero failures or skips; downloaded TRX/restore graph and GitHub artifact digest independently verified.
Full mixed repository run38187935885: 103 project/framework result rows, 7,865 passed, 144 skipped, zero failures. Skips remain explicit.
Integration tools run38187936041: 978 tests under normal and optimized Python, four conditional skips each; 71 release contracts, 15 activity contracts and four compiler fixture tests under each mode also passed.
Six Apps image profiles and project build job passed, alongside solution grouping, Secrets source contract and source-impact selection. The conditional affected-test job was skipped; it is not represented as executed runtime coverage.
Mapped-source artifact run38187935861 passed. Independent downloaded-archive hashes/source pins/package identities agree and publication is false. This is the retained historical mapped Slack contract, not Templates runtime certification; its one known upstream test skip and skipped pinned-source/released-artifact jobs remain explicit.
Fresh independent Spec+Standards reviews APPROVE/HIGH and Greptile5/5 cover this exact head. Zero unresolved threads. CodeRabbit's exact-head completion and advisory dispositions are recorded; no Copilot override is claimed.
Only consolidated package proof run38187936003 remains in progress. Templates is still the sole active delivery Task; no merge or final acceptance is claimed. Final actual-main integration/source cutoff remains #8749, followed by bounded #8740 closeout. Operational authority remains #8741.
Accepted on the shared integration branch through normal merge PR #8750, merge 5403eda00557c20e39306863d53213afb7308e55. Lead independently verified ordered parents 1d5bc1e1deaba8f2d90920109061a3504a945106 / c8d670e1681661f9c8a8873b1c2e8819e4ec1edb and exact candidate tree d7d2d2e89c905f1ed9374fd163897778bfdcbce6.
Original import retains all65 mapped assets/modes/blobs,41 original commits and17 recorded refs, including relevant3.8.0/3.9.0 history. Original PR9 and author are retained, with its applicable registration fix applied separately; all five Studio starter entrypoints now register custom elements. Donor issue3 remains an unresolved attributed report. Neither donor item was automatically closed.
Independent build/pack boundary and existing Elsa.Templates3.9.0 identity/three commands are preserved. Embedded projects remain data; root Core pack inventory excludes Templates. Real native exact-head pack/install/generate/assert/build ran20/20 cases, zero failures/skips. Earlier failed4752 and passed02ee results are retained separately; they are not substituted for currentc8d evidence.
Exact-head independent Spec+Standards APPROVE/HIGH, Greptile5/5, current advisory disposition, zero unresolved threads, and all21 successful checks/three conditional skips passed. Full repository suite:7,865 passed/144 skipped/zero failed. Package proof:232 packages/132 exclusions,464 archive hashes independently verified, clean representative consumer onnet8/9/10 and6admissioncells, publicationfalse. Final gate and artifact digest.
All four donors were refreshed immediately before merge, with no arrivals or changed recorded ref/contribution identities. Product docs record unsupported legacy standalone inputs and unverified options. Inherited Monaco/browser and production signing-key uncertainties remain explicitly documented under #8741; full release/publisher/Templates release work stays with #8725/#8741. No publication/deployment/archival or full runtime certification is claimed.
This closes the source slice and its Templates Feature on shared. #8749 now owns final source/history audit, contributor guidance, cutoff and reviewed actual-main integration; #8740 remains open until those outcomes are verified on main.
Activity
sfmskywalker commentedon Oct 11, 2026
Templates #8748 is the sole active delivery Task after Apps source acceptance. Board: In Progress / Assigned / Pending. Sol6.1High worker owns the first bounded mapping checkpoint; lead retains integration, public writes, review and QA.
Isolated branch
codex/elsa-templates-source-8748starts from accepted shared merge1d5bc1e1deaba8f2d90920109061a3504a945106, in/Users/sipke/.codex/worktrees/elsa-templates-8748-delivery/elsa-core-main. Clean HEAD/status verified. The actual Git worktree is valid; app registration and one retry hit the existing100attachment limit, which does not change isolation or require touching user checkouts.Fresh donor main is unchanged at
891759727db053a37911b616ace4a5599e1005d0; advertised release refs and sole open sourcePR95dc2c5cf4eb6ed17b2228912f712993e48adb56bare recorded. No matching Core Templates import PR exists. First checkpoint precedes edits and covers complete original-tree/history mapping, retained contribution attribution and applicable PR9 registration fix, local MSBuild/CPM/NuGet inheritance, independent template-pack/solution boundaries, isolated generated workspaces/hives and concrete20case pack/install/generate/build validation.No publisher activation, package upload, donor PR closure, retirement, archive, full release certification or Elsa4 work is assigned. Future candidate/archive compatibility remains with #8741/#8220. Final source audit and actual-main integration follow Templates; the program remains open.
sfmskywalker commentedon Oct 11, 2026
Templates implementation checkpoint: the immutable import
f1aaec368a9ad317093c71c993fb51eca2544e9epreserves the exact original tree0de85b0ca906f6be6559998768378f5c9fb03bb6, all 65 path/mode/blob mappings and all 41 original commits. The lead independently verified the eight ancestry parents and all retained ref commits. Applicable donor PR #9 is a separate attributed application commit79469e023b7a26b0ff6ca3a5a64104f654466ea2; its original commit and author timestamp remain retained.The separate Templates product solution/filter, scoped build/restore policy, outside-checkout test workspaces, root navigation and nonpublishing CI are implemented locally and undergoing review. Initial cheap checks passed: solution/filter generation, source-impact boundaries, retained publisher guards, Ruby dependency census and actionlint. Provenance/corruption tests and review fixes are still being completed. No native .NET or Docker proof has run locally on the overloaded shared host; exact-head hosted restore/build and all 20 real pack/install/generate/build cases remain required before acceptance.
Fresh donor main/release refs and outstanding source contributions are unchanged. The 35 accepted Core/Studio/Extensions release refs still match #8624 with no new unregistered 3.8.x/3.9.0 refs; Templates retains its 3.8.0 and 3.9.0 history. #8748 remains the only active delivery Task. #8749 stays queued for final source cutoff, actual-main integration and complete source closeout; operational work stays with #8741.
sfmskywalker commentedon Oct 11, 2026
Templates PR #8750 is open at
4752f5e7d4159fe7fb2aeb4a07e2c971ff62fc19. Independent source reviews approve that commit, but hosted lifecycle verification found a real build failure: 20 starter cases executed, 13 passed and 7 combined-host cases failed with CS1061 at the adopted custom-element registration. No merge or acceptance is claimed. The correction is in progress in the isolated Templates worktree; exactly one delivery task remains active. Owned expensive superseded CI runs were cancelled to avoid duplicate proof work.Failure evidence: https://github.com/elsa-workflows/elsa-core/actions/runs/38185751367/job/114607583652
sfmskywalker commentedon Oct 12, 2026
Current Templates source checkpoint: PR #8750 is at
02ee01951e44ba8ce83a10750a25c11bcee25947, with fresh independent Spec and Standards APPROVE/HIGH. The missing released namespace is corrected, with focused source regression and real20-case CI in progress. Greptile completed its predecessor4752 review at3/5 and identified additional missing custom-element registration in standaloneStudio and combinedWASM entrypoints. This is a genuine source-acceptance blocker covering the same starter setup as adopted donorPR9; the minimal correction and generated-output coverage are in progress. Owned expensive supersededCI was cancelled. No merge or acceptance is claimed.The inherited Monaco and production signing-key observations have byte-identical donor provenance, documented limitations and explicit operational handoff to #8741: #8741 (comment) . These are distinct from the bounded registration acceptance fix. #8748 remains the sole active Task; #8749 stays queued.
sfmskywalker commentedon Oct 12, 2026
Current complete-registration head
c8d670e1681661f9c8a8873b1c2e8819e4ec1edbpassed the real20-case Templates lifecycle; the lead independently verified TRX, scoped restore graph and artifact digest. Evidence: #8750 (comment) . Fresh exact-head independent reviews approve. Broader CI/package proof and Greptile remain in progress; #8748 stays the sole active Task, In Progress / In Review / Running. Final #8749 source cutoff/main integration remains queued.sfmskywalker commentedon Oct 12, 2026
Exact-head checkpoint for PR #8750 at
c8d670e1681661f9c8a8873b1c2e8819e4ec1edb:Only consolidated package proof run38187936003 remains in progress. Templates is still the sole active delivery Task; no merge or final acceptance is claimed. Final actual-main integration/source cutoff remains #8749, followed by bounded #8740 closeout. Operational authority remains #8741.
sfmskywalker commentedon Oct 12, 2026
Accepted on the shared integration branch through normal merge PR #8750, merge
5403eda00557c20e39306863d53213afb7308e55. Lead independently verified ordered parents1d5bc1e1deaba8f2d90920109061a3504a945106/c8d670e1681661f9c8a8873b1c2e8819e4ec1edband exact candidate treed7d2d2e89c905f1ed9374fd163897778bfdcbce6.Original import retains all65 mapped assets/modes/blobs,41 original commits and17 recorded refs, including relevant3.8.0/3.9.0 history. Original PR9 and author are retained, with its applicable registration fix applied separately; all five Studio starter entrypoints now register custom elements. Donor issue3 remains an unresolved attributed report. Neither donor item was automatically closed.
Independent build/pack boundary and existing Elsa.Templates3.9.0 identity/three commands are preserved. Embedded projects remain data; root Core pack inventory excludes Templates. Real native exact-head pack/install/generate/assert/build ran20/20 cases, zero failures/skips. Earlier failed4752 and passed02ee results are retained separately; they are not substituted for currentc8d evidence.
Exact-head independent Spec+Standards APPROVE/HIGH, Greptile5/5, current advisory disposition, zero unresolved threads, and all21 successful checks/three conditional skips passed. Full repository suite:7,865 passed/144 skipped/zero failed. Package proof:232 packages/132 exclusions,464 archive hashes independently verified, clean representative consumer onnet8/9/10 and6admissioncells, publicationfalse. Final gate and artifact digest.
All four donors were refreshed immediately before merge, with no arrivals or changed recorded ref/contribution identities. Product docs record unsupported legacy standalone inputs and unverified options. Inherited Monaco/browser and production signing-key uncertainties remain explicitly documented under #8741; full release/publisher/Templates release work stays with #8725/#8741. No publication/deployment/archival or full runtime certification is claimed.
This closes the source slice and its Templates Feature on shared. #8749 now owns final source/history audit, contributor guidance, cutoff and reviewed actual-main integration; #8740 remains open until those outcomes are verified on main.
Import original Elsa Templates source and history under templates/
Register custom Studio elements in combined server templates
Integrate independent Elsa Templates build and source validation